I’ve often heard this passage described as a contrast between two leaders. First, we encounter Herod, a man so caught up in his own wickedness that he has John the Baptist executed. He married his brother’s wife and then his niece, both of whom were condemned in Leviticus. The author of Matthew paints Herod as *almost* remorseful … but not enough to change. Not enough to be held accountable. Not enough to let conviction lead to repentance. No, he really commits to the path he’s chosen, doesn’t he? 

Immediately following this disturbing scene, we read one of the most famous stories in the Gospels: Jesus feeding the 5,000. Jesus has just received the devastating news about his cousin, John the Baptist. He understandably needs to get away to grieve. However, as was so often the case, the crowds (who represent us in the Gospels) follow Jesus and find him, and Jesus decides to pause with them rather than commit to his getaway. 

Jesus doesn’t ignore his own need for rest (Jesus DOES get away after this), but he’s willing to pause. Jesus is so committed to the health of the people that, in his compassion, he stops to heal the sick and then feeds the masses. His leadership is marked by attentiveness, flexibility, and deep care for the dignity and well-being of the people. 

Consider now the difference between the leadership styles of Jesus and Herod: 

  • Which leader demonstrates trustworthiness?
  • Which one is loyal to mission? 
  • Which one is able to pivot to meet the needs of the situation? 
  • Which one protects honor and dignity?

N.T. Wright offers a helpful warning here: We shouldn’t assume we are meant to identify with John the Baptist. Rather, we can allow this passage to hold up a mirror to us: “What small weaknesses in our lives are we allowing to grow unchecked that might one day produce real wickedness? What Herod-like characteristics are lurking inside us, waiting for a chance to destroy us or others?” (Wright, “Matthew for Everyone,” p. 184)

This is the reason Jesus came—for the sin that does indeed lurk in our hearts. He isn’t a resurrected John the Baptist, as Herod fears, but rather the one who takes all our weakness, brokenness, and sin to the cross. He bears that shame so we might be free, and the Herod-like qualities within us won’t separate us from God’s love. 

Reflection: 

  • Which of Jesus’ leadership styles in today’s passage would you like to emulate? 
  • What Herod-like tendencies can you see growing in your life that need to be submitted to the healing power of God’s love? 
  • When is the last time you confessed or surrendered those uncomfortable parts of your heart to God?